On Anonymity as Trolling
01December2010
[myth]
[tweet this]
Julie Zhou, a product design manager at Facebook, has an opinion piece on anonymity in the NY Times, being heavily linked around the web.
Morality, Plato argues, comes from full disclosure; without accountability for our actions we would all behave unjustly.
My first reaction was mere twitter-sized; it just looks like the NY Times are the next in a long line of people rediscovering GIFT (John Gabriel’s Greater Internet F***wad Theory). There’s nothing new here — it’s long been obvious that anonymity is responsible for the lion’s share of online trolling, and moreover, that that stems from human nature.
But when I noticed that Zhou writes from Facebook, the article became a whole lot more interesting, and my reading of it changed. Consider:
Instead of waiting around for human nature to change, let’s start to rein in bad behavior by promoting accountability. Content providers, stop allowing anonymous comments. Moderate your comments and forums. Look into using comment services to improve the quality of engagement on your site. Ask your users to report trolls and call them out for polluting the conversation.
In slowly lifting the veil of anonymity, perhaps we can see the troll not as the frightening monster of lore, but as what we all really are: human.
It seems that Facebook’s well documented disdain for privacy is being spun in a different way within those walls — they don’t want to out people, they want to prevent trolling. But this logic sees the “veil of anonymity” only as a bad thing — something that encourages bad behaviour. There’s no room in that world for people hiding behind the veil because they can’t be truely themselves in the real world, or because they genuinely fear being exposed. If it’s only Facebook, that’s one thing, but when they want to spread their worldview to other providers as well, people desiring anonymity will have few places left to hide.
« On Facebook and Messaging :: Travel Log I »
Related [myth]
- On the PlayBook (09May2011)
- On Chatter and What Matters (30March2011)
- On Anonymity as Trolling (01December2010)
- On Music (06October2010)
- Five Things (30August2010)
- On Work (22November2009)
- The Space Race (28May2009)
- On Chatter (20May2009)
- Not The Mobile Web, just A mobile web (13July2008)
- Melbourne, Je t'aime (13March2008)
- Slouching Towards Bedlam (02January2008)
- War & Politics (10October2007)
- Crises of faith (16August2007)
- Green is a Status Symbol (13July2007)
- The Author and The Logos (11June2006)
- Who Says Computers Aren't Intelligent? (26May2006)
- On Being Marketed Down To (11May2006)
- Venus and Mars and some other planet (14April2006)
- Team B Mark II (13April2006)
- Rehearsing for Fourty Thousand Years; On Cultural Curiosity (10April2006)
- When Myth-Making Backfires (22February2006)
- Vanishing From View (19February2006)
- Rethinking Judas (03February2006)
- Places of Departure (04January2006)
- Public Schooling, Religion, A Manifesto (17December2005)
- Australian Identity and Online Writing (11December2005)
- The Universal Library (02December2005)
- Turing's Cathedral (29October2005)
- I don't HATE Microsoft (28October2005)
- Reclaiming the label Amateur (27October2005)
- That's not a knife (22October2005)
- Some observations on 'Spam 2.0' (17October2005)
- Bird Flu (15October2005)
- Computing isn't meant to be Easy (15October2005)
- "How a faithful nation gets Jesus wrong" (09October2005)
- Pollution != Global Warming (07October2005)
- Bible truth (06October2005)
- Starbucks (15September2005)
- JK Rowling Interview (06August2005)
- Woo! Drink Good (03August2005)
- 'the Jedi Order, the geekiest people in the universe' (20July2005)
- Did you sell any goods or services using the Internet? (19July2005)
- Connectivity (13July2005)
- bourgeois myth (25June2005)
- press-ganging alive and well (10June2005)
- With Us or Against Us (01June2005)
- It's Non (29May2005)
- lesser of two evils (06May2005)
- God's Rottweiler (26April2005)
- In the Public Interests of Whom? (11April2005)
- 'threats that no one country, however powerful, can fight alone' (22March2005)
- So what are your politics? (17March2005)
- Trade-Slave (20January2005)
- Elves Of Valinor Warn Of 'Critical Security Flaw' in Palantir Browsers (16January2005)
- four legs good, two legs ... (12January2005)
- Acts of God (04January2005)
- what terrorism may achieve (22December2004)
- My Favourite Book (06December2004)
- Terrorist Descent (06December2004)
- more Centrists (04December2004)
- kill everyone (10November2004)
- trendy lefties (09November2004)
- digital delivery (30September2004)
- appeasement is a dirty word (10September2004)
- pro-one-choice (07September2004)
- another little victory (10August2004)
- Artorius Rex-tended (23July2004)
- Crazy Irish-Catholic terrorists (23July2004)
- Five and a half pages (23July2004)
- I knew he was stupid, but really... (16July2004)
- Artorius Rex (16July2004)
- 'at no time did australian troops...' (27June2004)
- cut and run (17May2004)
- Abort (25April2004)
- The Passion Part I (22April2004)
- the light in the darkness (18April2004)
- woundedness (18April2004)
- Chromies (15April2004)
- Fortress Australia (12April2004)
- The Passion Pre-Viewing (04March2004)
- 'the desire to be a patriot and to change things' (18February2004)
- I want to be a Free Spirit (14February2004)
- Broken Hearts (14February2004)